5. Detector Construction
5.1 Geometry of the Detector Cell:
5.1.1 Three basic types of β-ray ionization-detector geom-
etries can be considered applicable as electron-capture detector
cells: the parallel-plate design, the concentric-tube or coaxial-
tube design, and recessed electrode or asymmetric type (36-
39). The latter could be considered a variation of the
concentric-tube design. Both the plane-plate geometry and
concentric geometry are used almost exclusively for pulsed
operation. Although the asymmetric configuration is primarily
employed in the d-c operation of electron-capture detectors, a
unique version of the asymmetric design (referred to as a
displaced-coaxial-cylinder geometry) has been developed for
pulse-modulated operation. The optimum mode of operation is
usually different for each detector geometry and this must be
considered, where necessary, in choosing certain operating
parameters.
5.1.2 In general, more efficient operation is achieved if the
detector is polarized such that the gas flow is counter to the
flow of electrons toward the anode. In this regard, the radio-
active source should be placed at the cathode or as near to it as
possible.
5.1.3 Other geometric factors that affect cell response and
operation are cell volume and electrode spacing, which may or
may not be altered concurrently depending upon the construc-
tion of the detector. Of course, both these variables can be
significant at the extremes, and optimum values will also
depend upon other parameters of operation. In the pulsed
operational mode, the electrons within the cell must be able to
reach the anode or collector electrode during the 0.1 to 1.0 µs
voltage pulse. Generally, electrode distances of 0.5 to 1.0 cm
are acceptable and can be used optimally by the proper choice
of operating conditions. Cell volume should be small enough to
maintain effective electron capture without encountering other
types of electron reactions and also small enough so as not to
lose any resolution that may have been achieved by high-
resolution chromatographic systems. Typical ECD cell vol-
umes range from approximately 2 to 0.3 cm
3
. A detector cell
with a relatively low internal volume is particularly important
when the ECD is used with open tubular columns. In addition
to the preceding electrical and chromatographic requirements,
the electrode dimensions of the detector are also determined by
the range of the particular β-rays.
5.2 Radioactive Source:
5.2.1 Many β-ray-emitting isotopes can be used as the
primary ionization source. The two most suitable are
3
H
(tritium) (40,41). and
63
Ni (42).
5.2.1.1 Tritium—This isotope is usually coated on 302
stainless steel or Hastelloy C, which is a nickel-base alloy. The
tritium attached to the former foil material is in the form of
Ti
3
H
2
; however, there is uncertainty concerning the exact
means of tritium attachment to the scandium (Sc) substrate of
the Hastelloy C foil. The proposed methods of attachment
include Sc
3
H
3
and
3
H
2
as the occluded gas. The nominal source
activity for tritium is 250 mCi in titanium sources and 1000
mCi in scandium sources. Department of Energy regulations
permit a maximum operating temperature of 225 °C for the
Ti
3
H
2
source and 325 °C for the Sc
3
H
3
source. Naturally,
detector temperatures that are less than the maximum values
will lengthen the lifetimes of the tritiated sources by reducing
the tritium emanation rates. The newer scandium sources are
more effective at minimizing the contamination problems
associated with electron-capture detectors because of their
capability for operation at 325 °C. Furthermore, the tritiated-
scandium source displays a factor-of-three detectability in-
crease for dissociative electron-capturing species, that is,
halogenated molecules. Another advantage of scandium tritide
sources is their availability at much higher specific activities
than nickel-63 sources; therefore, Sc
3
H
3
sources are smaller
and permit the construction of detector cells with smaller
internal volumes. The maximum energy of the β-rays emitted
by tritium is 0.018 MeV.
5.2.1.2 Nickel-63 (
63
Ni)—This radioactive isotope is usu-
ally either electroplated directly on a gold foil in the detector
cell or is plated directly onto the interior of the cell block.
Since the maximum energy of the β-rays from the
63
Ni is 0.067
MeV and
63
Ni is a more effective radiation source than tritium,
the normal
63
Ni activity is typically 10 to 15 mCi. An
advantage of
63
Ni is its ability to be heated to 350 °C and the
concomitant decrease in detector contamination during chro-
matographic operation. Another advantage of the high detector
temperatures available with
63
Ni is an enhanced sensitivity for
compounds that undergo dissociative electron capture.
5.2.2 Although the energies and the practical source
strengths for these two radioactive isotopes are different, no
significant differences in the results of operation need be
encountered. However, optimum interelectrode distance in the
detector cell is generally greater for
63
Ni than for tritium, that
is, less than 2.5 mm for tritium and 10 mm for
63
Ni. Thus,
tritium sources have the potential of greater sensitivity for
those compounds which undergo undissociative electron at-
tachment because of tritium’s higher specific activity and its
ability to be used in a smaller volume detector. Because low
levels of radioactive
3
H or
63
Ni are released to the laboratory
environment, it is a wise safety precaution to vent electron-
capture detectors by means of hood exhaust systems.
5.3 Operational Modes:
5.3.1 Three operational modes are presently available with
commercial electron-capture detectors: constant-dc-voltage
method (43), constant-frequency method, and the constant-
current method (44-49). Within each mode of operation, there
lies the ability to optimize performance by selective adjust-
ments of various ECD operational parameters. This may
include, among other things, not only the choice of reagent gas
to be used in the ECD (see 5.4) but also setting the detector’s
pulse time constant on the electrometer to correspond to the gas
used.
5.3.1.1 DC-Voltage Method—A negative d-c voltage is ap-
plied to the cathode resulting in an increasing detector current
with increasing voltage until saturation is reached. The ECD
response for the d-c mode is only linear over a narrow voltage
range of approximately 10 to 15 V. Therefore, optimum
operation is obtained when the detector current is about 80 %
of the saturation level. At higher voltages, the response
becomes nonlinear and this nonlinearity becomes extreme on
the saturation plateau. At d-c voltages below the optimum
E697 − 96 (2026)
3